Where AI Actually Delivers ROI, And Where It Doesn’t

The “We Need an App” Effect, Now Rebranded as AI

A few years ago, every company believed it needed an app.

It did not matter whether the organization was a restaurant, bank, or nonprofit. Eventually someone in leadership would say, “We need an app.”

Most of them did not.

What they actually needed were stronger processes, better systems, and more consistent follow up. But an app sounded innovative, so the budget was allocated toward the wrong solution.

We are seeing the same pattern emerge with AI.

Leaders say, “We need an AI strategy.”
Boards ask, “What’s our AI roadmap?”
Teams begin experimenting with ambitious, high visibility use cases.

Meanwhile, the strongest ROI opportunities remain inside existing workflows, untouched.

‍

Where AI Delivers the Strongest Return

AI consistently delivers measurable ROI in areas that are:

• Repetitive

• Measurable

• Operationally painful

• Already consuming trusted human time

In secure enterprise environments, this often includes:

• Reporting processes that consume hours each week

• Manual ticket or alert triage before real work begins

• Proposal or documentation drafts that always start from zero

• Data sets that exist but remain unanalyzed due to bandwidth limits

These initiatives are not flashy. They do not generate headlines. But they compound.

If you save five hours per week across ten employees, that is not a demo; it is measurable capacity. It leads to faster execution, improved response time, stronger compliance posture, and reduced burnout.

From a security perspective, this also reduces risk exposure caused by fatigue and rushed manual processes.

Practical Security Implementation Ideas:

• Automate first pass security alert summarization before analyst review

• Use AI to assist in compliance reporting and audit preparation

• Apply AI driven data analysis to identify patterns in incident history

• Standardize AI assisted documentation within secure environments

Start with workflows where time and friction are already visible.

‍

Where AI Fails to Deliver ROI

AI initiatives struggle when expectations are vague.

Statements like:

“Let’s use AI to transform customer experience.”
“Let’s build an AI powered product.”
“Let’s automate everything.”

These goals may sound visionary, but without defined operational friction, they rarely produce measurable returns.

Projects become exploratory and expensive. Evaluation becomes subjective. Momentum slows because no one can clearly point to a concrete win.

In security sensitive organizations, this can introduce additional risk. Experimental deployments without defined outcomes often expand tool sprawl, increase integration complexity, and create governance blind spots.

Big vision without operational clarity rarely translates into ROI.

‍

The Real Driver of AI ROI: Friction Removal

The strongest AI return does not come from moonshots.

It comes from friction removal.

Identify the work your team repeats every week. The manual review steps before meaningful action occurs. The tasks that are necessary but drain focus.

Then measure:

• Time saved

• Error reduction

• Cycle speed

• Risk reduction

Once measurable gains are visible, expansion becomes logical and controlled.

Practical Security Implementation Ideas:

• Measure reduction in false positive review time after AI assisted filtering

• Track compliance documentation cycle time before and after automation

• Monitor reduction in manual log correlation effort

AI is a multiplier, but only when applied to something concrete.

Apply leverage to the wrong area and nothing moves. Apply it to real operational resistance and the impact becomes obvious.

‍

The Organizations Seeing Real Return

The companies seeing meaningful AI ROI are not necessarily the ones making the loudest announcements.

They are the ones quietly eliminating wasted effort inside secure operations.

They are reducing repetitive analyst workload.
They are accelerating documentation cycles.
They are strengthening oversight while improving productivity.

That is where ROI lives.

Not in ambition alone, but in measurable friction removed from real work.

‍

FAQs: AI ROI in Security Focused Organizations

1. How can security teams measure AI ROI effectively?
Track time saved on repetitive tasks, reduction in manual review hours, decreased error rates, and improved response time. Tie results to operational metrics already monitored by leadership.

2. Why do large AI transformation projects often stall?
Because they lack defined friction and measurable outcomes. Without a clear baseline and success criteria, it becomes difficult to prove value or maintain momentum.

3. What is the safest place to start with AI for measurable ROI?
Begin with repetitive, low judgment tasks inside controlled, approved environments. Reporting, documentation, and structured data analysis typically provide fast, measurable returns with manageable risk.